I spent a lot of the last two weeks in New York City simply wandering the streets, from early in the morning until late at night. The scale of the architecture is amazing. To turn a corner and be confronted with the eight story stone footing of a bridge filling the space between buildings, and carrying a further ten stories of steel up into the night air, is breathtaking. The general style is a utilitarian one that I find quite beautiful; painted steel held together with great bolts and huge rivets rather than the glass and concrete favoured today.
Years ago I had come across Joel Sternfeld’s photographs of the High Line, a disused elevated rail line on the west side of Manhattan, and instantly wanted to go. His photographs show a small area of elevated wilderness cutting through perhaps the most iconically metropolitan city in the west. In the years after the lines closure and abandonment wild grasses had closed in upon the steel tracks, and saplings had pushed their way through the track ballast and shot up to above head height. Beautiful.
Now, however, the part of the High Line that remains has been transformed into a park. As nice as the new park is with its innovative fountain and moveable wooden benches that span the distance between tracks, it’s paved footpaths now give you one more place to walk on cement in a city made of the stuff. Sternfeld’s photographs give the feeling that nature was reclaiming it’s space, now the sense is that nature has been caught, contained, trapped, and now is allowed to stay only as long as it stays in its cage and doesn’t piss on the rug. I wish I had visited the High Line before it’s regeneration. OK, it was more exclusive as you had to break the law and climb to go see it, but wow. As I walked along the track I couldn’t help noticing a piece of graffiti on a neighbouring building that simply read “RIP High Line”.
On Roosevelt Island the decaying ruins of a former smallpox hospital is having similar construction work done to it. Seeing these has made me think about our desire to remove the offensive parts from our past, to turn them into something that is banal and inoffensive. I suppose in a place where room is as tight as it is on the island of Manhattan letting a space become reclaimed by nature is hard to justify, but in a country with such a short history it seems a shame to remove what little they have.
Who controls the past, controls the future. Who Controls the present, controls the past.
The other obvious place in New York that is currently being redeveloped is the former site of the World Trade Centre, the infamous Ground Zero. Will the new monument really commemorate the event of 9/11? What can you say with stone and glass that properly signifies the world-changing event the took place there. Whatever they build it will not be as savage, brutal and sublime as the twin towers crashing to the ground. Surely, if you want to never forget the best monument would be to leave the gnarled, twisted metal and crumbled concrete that made up the wreckage.
Huge, sublime, phallic symbols of capitalist power that sky scrapers are, who would want people to remember how fragile they really are? Whatever they do build, for me there is one monument that really made me think about what happened: framed by the downtown buildings of New York’s financial district, there is an area of sky that was once filled by steel and glass and concrete and people.
Posted on 11/10/11 in Documentary, Photography, Theory, Travel 0 Comments



























